Summary
Racine County’s own disciplinary file says a captain was warned about Deputy Preston Kite in 2023 and conducted no investigation; Kite was later convicted of 21 felonies involving children. The county paid $31,828.38 for an outside review and has refused to release it. In October 2026 a second warning—about a Union Grove school superintendent—went through the same command staff, the subject was contacted before his phones were examined, and Kenosha County again made the arrest. H.O.T. Government examines what was known, what was kept off the record, and what the county still will not produce.
Key findings
ACTIVE INVESTIGATION — HALL REPORT SEALED · RECORDS OUTSTANDING · UPDATED NOVEMBER 8, 2026
How documented warnings about a Racine County deputy were handled informally, left untracked, and followed by unanswered questions about supervision, internal relationships, and withheld public records.
Featured question
When government officials keep serious complaints informal, is the misconduct undocumented—or the accountability?
The crime — and what this investigation asks
Preston Kite was employed as a Racine County Sheriff’s deputy. On February 3, 2024, a member of the public reported that Kite, in full uniform, had exposed himself in a public bathroom and tried to coerce the complainant into a stall. Racine County asked the Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department to investigate; Kenosha arrested him the next day and found child sexual abuse material on his devices. Kite pleaded guilty. On February 28, 2025, he was convicted of 21 felonies and sentenced to 55 years of initial confinement and 90 years in total. His criminal conduct is established through the criminal proceedings.
This H.O.T. investigation focuses on a different question: What did Racine County officials know before the arrest, how did they respond, and what did they place—or fail to place—on the official record?
The warnings
Racine County Sheriff’s Office Internal File No. 25DC20 identifies Captain Cary Madrigal as the command officer who was made aware of Kite’s conduct in the summer and fall of 2023—months before the arrest. The conduct reported to her was adult-to-adult: unsolicited nude photographs Kite sent to other deputies, and walking in on a deputy who was changing. Nothing involving children was reported to her. In the summer of 2023 Madrigal herself raised “the Kite stuff” with a supervisor in a hallway and asked him to “talk to Kite”; in November 2023 a deputy raised it directly in her office. (Sheriff Schmaling’s complaint places the hallway exchange in summer 2023; Attorney Hall’s own report placed it after the November meeting. The Sheriff overrode his investigator on that point.)
Those matters were reportedly handled informally: no written report, no formal investigation, while Kite remained on active duty. The department’s own disciplinary finding described the institutional consequence:
“I was also informed that supervisory staff were aware of these allegations and did not take formal steps to address the situation.”
Sheriff Christopher Schmaling, Disciplinary Complaint, RASO Internal File No. 25DC20 (Feb. 19, 2025)
Known to supervisors — missing from the paper trail
When a Kenosha County detective investigated Kite’s criminal case, Racine County supervisors reportedly told the outside investigator that complaints involving Kite already existed. That creates a contradiction: the concerns were known well enough to describe to another county’s investigator, yet no written internal complaint or formal investigation appears to have been created when the concerns were first reported.
Open-court allegations that went unanswered
At sentencing, Kite made a statement in open court alleging sexual relationships involving people connected to law enforcement, including two other deputies, a supervisor in his department, and an assistant district attorney from a neighboring county. He also claimed he had reached out to supervisors as his condition deteriorated and received no meaningful follow-up.
Those statements are allegations. They do not prove misconduct by every person referenced. They do raise questions that ordinarily warrant examination—who was identified, who was interviewed, whether conflicts of interest were assessed, and whether any referral was made to the Wisconsin Department of Justice or the FBI. According to the available public record assembled for this case, no broader public investigation followed and the individuals were not publicly identified.
The supervisor–landlord question
Internal investigation materials reportedly included hearsay that Kite rented his residence from Capt. Madrigal. The investigator did not pursue the issue. Racine County District Attorney Patricia Hanson later told H.O.T. that county records showed the allegation was untrue. H.O.T. then reviewed Racine County Register of Deeds records for the Union Grove duplex where Kite lived.
Those deeds show Nancy K. Mueller retained a life estate—legal authority to occupy, control, and collect rent during Kite’s residence. Mueller’s published obituary lists Cary Madrigal among surviving grandchildren. The records do not establish personal ownership or rent collection by Madrigal. They do identify a family connection to the life-estate holder and raise why the possible relationship was not examined with documentary follow-up during the county’s internal investigation.
District Attorney response
In a June 18, 2026 written response, DA Hanson confirmed that her office did not handle Kite’s criminal case and made no referrals to the FBI or Wisconsin DOJ concerning the deputies, supervisor, or neighboring-county prosecutor referenced at sentencing.
Records still outstanding
On June 8, 2026, H.O.T. submitted public-records requests to the Racine County Sheriff’s Office, Human Resources, and Corporation Counsel. The Sheriff’s Office has never answered: not the June 8 request, not a certified-mail request delivered July 6, and not a nine-item request served on Sheriff Schmaling in person on August 15, 2026. Corporation Counsel answered for HR and itself on July 29 and August 3 (Requests 26-117 and 26-123): “no responsive records” on any pre-arrest HR complaint, on any mandatory-reporting assessment, and on any record of why ten days was chosen over termination; everything about the decision to commission Attorney Hall’s review rather than refer the matter to the Wisconsin DOJ or FBI withheld as privileged; and “no such named document” defining the scope of Hall’s engagement. On August 6 H.O.T. requested the Hall Report itself; Corporation Counsel denied it in full on August 11—primary election day—under a blanket claim of attorney-client privilege, while conceding that a written balancing analysis exists. The County Clerk’s October 13 production shows Racine County paid Crivello Nichols & Hall $31,828.38 for the review. On October 22 the first records ever produced at the Sheriff’s Office’s direction arrived, 114 days after they were requested. The Hall Report remains sealed. H.O.T. has retained counsel for a mandamus action under Wis. Stat. § 19.37.
Key findings
- Supervisors received direct complaints before Kite’s arrest (summer and fall of 2023, per Internal File No. 25DC20).
- Complaints were handled informally—no formal report or investigation at the time.
- The county’s outside investigator found that Madrigal “did not conduct any independent investigation” and that Kite “was not interviewed about anything.” She received a ten-day unpaid suspension and signed a waiver of her hearing.
- Supervisors later disclosed the existence of prior complaints to Kenosha investigators.
- Kite made serious open-court allegations; the available record does not show a broader public inquiry.
- A possible supervisor–housing connection was noted as hearsay and not fully investigated; deeds and an obituary later identified a family life-estate connection.
- The District Attorney’s Office reported no outside referrals on the sentencing allegations.
- Important county records remain outstanding.
Evidence library (documents sought / cited)
- Racine County Sheriff’s Office Internal File No. 25DC20
- Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department Field Case Report No. 2024-00304801
- State v. Kite sentencing transcript — Racine County Circuit Court Nos. 2024CF000164 and 2024CF000247
- Racine County Register of Deeds Nos. 2191400, 2191401, 2685746, 2688814
- Nancy Mueller obituary
- Motion to Suppress Evidence, United States v. Westbrook (W.D. Wis.), and Defendant’s Reply thereto
- Government’s Response to Defendant’s Motion to Withdraw Plea, Dkt. 73 (filed Nov. 17, 2025)
- Government’s Response to Court’s Request to View Charged Images, Dkt. 74 (filed Nov. 28, 2025)
- Notice of Appeal, Dkt. 111 (filed May 27, 2026); Seventh Circuit No. 26-2132
- District Attorney Patricia Hanson letter (June 18, 2026)
- Public-records correspondence (June 8–July 22, 2026)
- Public-records correspondence (July 29, 2026)
- Kenosha Public-records correspondence (August, 2026)
October 22, 2026: it happened again
On October 22, 2026, an anonymous letter alleging that the Union Grove High School superintendent had inappropriate messages and photographs involving students on his phone was delivered to the school board, the principal, and the Union Grove Chief of Police. The same day it was in the hands of Racine County Sheriff’s Office “Administration.” According to the Kenosha County criminal complaint filed November 5, Administration contacted the Lieutenant of Investigations, who had no investigators on duty and assigned the matter for the next morning because the letter stated no emergency.
Also that day, by the superintendent’s own account to Kenosha detectives, someone from the Racine County Sheriff’s Office visited him at the school and discussed the investigation—before any device had been examined. When investigators examined his phones on October 23 they were “suspiciously clean.” He had deleted Snapchat and his browsing history, and later factory-reset his work phone.
On October 27–28 the case was transferred to Kenosha County; RASO’s stated reason was that a Racine deputy is stationed at the school. Kenosha obtained warrants, identified child sexual abuse material, and arrested the superintendent on November 4. He is charged with two felony counts of possession of child pornography and is presumed innocent. The Kenosha detective wrote that he had been told about the investigation before it was assigned to Kenosha.
On November 7 the Sheriff’s Office confirmed that Captain Madrigal had been placed on administrative leave pending “a pending internal administrative review of Captain Madrigal’s actions,” and said she “is not the focus or subject of the criminal investigation.” The complaint does not identify who from the Sheriff’s Office contacted the superintendent on October 22. H.O.T. Government has requested that record.
Both men lived or worked in the Village of Union Grove. Both cases began with a warning to the Racine County Sheriff’s Office. In both, the subject was reached—or never reached at all—before the evidence was. In both, Kenosha County made the arrest.
H.O.T. Government’s position
H.O.T. characterizes the pattern in these records as institutional concealment in practice: informal complaints, no written tracking, a narrowly scoped internal investigation, courtroom allegations left unexplored, questions closed without full documentary review, and delayed records. That is H.O.T.’s interpretation of the evidence—not a judicial finding.
“Off the books. Every time.” Readers should review the source documents and reach their own conclusions.
Corrections
This page has been corrected since first publication (July 28, 2026). H.O.T. Government’s corrections policy requires that we say so.
- Sentence and counts. Earlier versions said Kite was sentenced to 65 years and charged with 45 felonies. The court record shows 21 felony convictions and a sentence of 55 years of initial confinement, 90 years in total.
- The 2023 complaints. Earlier versions described “direct complaints received in June 2023 and November 2023.” The file shows Madrigal herself raised the matter with a supervisor in summer 2023 and a deputy raised it in her office in November 2023; the two accounts of their order differ between the Sheriff and his investigator.
- Nature of the complaints. The conduct reported to Madrigal in 2023 concerned adults, not children. Earlier H.O.T. materials that described the warnings as being about children overstated the record.
- A quotation. A sentence attributed to the county’s findings about “institutional tracking” did not appear in the file and has been removed.
- The courtroom statement. Kite’s February 28, 2025 statement was an unsworn allocution, in open court and on the record—not sworn testimony.
- The arrest. The arrest followed a complaint that Kite exposed himself in a public bathroom, not a report of his patrol vehicle.
Editorial and legal note
This investigation concerns institutional conduct, supervision, documentation, and government accountability. Unless supported by a conviction or formal adjudication, allegations involving unnamed deputies, supervisors, prosecutors, or other individuals remain clearly labeled as allegations. No person should be described as having committed a crime solely because Kite named or referenced them. All persons named are presumed innocent unless proven otherwise in court. Separate campaign-conduct issues connected to the 2026 sheriff’s race are handled as a different H.O.T. investigation.
Timeline
-
The Telegram window
Federal prosecutors date Adam Westbrook's conduct in a Telegram group called "Dads and Uncles" to May 21, 2023 through March 1, 2024. Prosecutors state that Westbrook administered the group and that access required submitting a nude photograph of a child under 13. Preston Kite remained a Racine County Sheriff's deputy throughout this period. [21][22]
-
Madrigal raises “the Kite stuff” with a supervisor
Per Internal File No. 25DC20, Capt. Cary Madrigal approaches a supervisor in a hallway, says she has heard about “the Kite stuff,” and asks him to “talk to Kite.” No complaint form, no investigation. (The Sheriff dates this to summer 2023; Attorney Hall placed it after the November meeting.)
-
A deputy raises Kite in Madrigal’s office
A deputy who received an unsolicited nude photo from Kite raises it directly in Madrigal’s office, using the words “sexual harassment.” Madrigal acknowledges she has “heard those rumors.” Again handled informally. Kite remains on active duty and is under consideration for the LGBTQ Liaison position. [3][12]
-
Kite and Westbrook exchange videos
While the second Sheriff's Office complaint remained informal, a federal court filing in United States v. Westbrook states that a search of Adam Westbrook's iPad revealed a November 23, 2023 text exchange with Kite. The two exchanged three videos, two depicting solo sexual activity. Regarding one subject, Kite wrote that the person said he was 18, adding, "doubt that lol looks 14 if not younger." Neither man was charged specifically for this exchange. [20]
-
Federal prosecutors describe anticipated evidence
In a filing describing evidence the United States said it would have presented to a jury, prosecutors listed messages in which the recipient of Westbrook's videos—identified elsewhere in the case record as Racine County Deputy Sheriff Preston Kite—admitted to being a "P*do." The filing also described chats in which the two discussed a shared attraction to underage boys, exchanged child sexual abuse material, and Westbrook told his mother that he sent the charged videos because the recipient "gets off by seeing kids." [22]
-
Arrest and Kenosha investigation
A member of the public reports that Kite, in uniform, exposed himself in a public bathroom. Racine County asks Kenosha County to investigate; Kenosha arrests him February 4. Kenosha’s report records that Racine supervisors told the detective complaints about Kite already existed.
-
Ten-day suspension
Sheriff Schmaling files a six-page summary of Attorney Hall’s findings with the Grievance Committee. Finding: Madrigal “did not take any appropriate actions” in 2023. Penalty: ten days without pay. Madrigal signs a waiver of her hearing the next day. The Hall Report itself is not released.
-
Sentencing and open-court statement
Kite is convicted of 21 felonies and sentenced to 55 years of initial confinement, 90 years in total. In an unsworn statement in open court, he alleges sexual relationships involving two deputies, a supervisor within his department, and an assistant district attorney from a neighboring county. Those allegations remain unexamined in the public record.
-
Sentencing transcript filed
The sentencing transcript enters the public court record, preserving Kite's open-court statement for independent review.
-
Westbrook sentenced in federal court
Adam Westbrook is sentenced to ten years in federal prison followed by twenty years of supervised release. Judgment is entered May 18, 2026. A notice of appeal is filed May 27, and the appeal remains pending in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit as Case No. 26-2132. [23]
-
Public-records requests and DA response
H.O.T. Government submits public-records requests to the Sheriff's Office, Human Resources, and Corporation Counsel. District Attorney Patricia Hanson responds in writing on June 18, stating that no outside referrals were made.
-
Corporation Counsel delay notice
Corporation Counsel indicates that it hopes to fulfill the records requests within approximately three weeks, without initially providing a firm production date.
-
Investigation published
Racine County’s own disciplinary file says a captain was warned about Deputy Preston Kite in 2023 and conducted no investigation; Kite was later convicted of 21 felonies involving children. The county paid $31,828.38 for an outside review and has refused to release it. In October 2026 a second warning—about a Union Grove school superintendent—went through the same command staff, the subject was contacted before his phones were examined, and Kenosha County again made the arrest. H.O.T. Government examines what was known, what was kept off the record, and what the county still will not produce.
-
Corporation Counsel answers for HR: no records
Requests 26-117 and 26-123: “no responsive records” on any pre-arrest HR complaint, any mandatory-reporting assessment, or any record of why ten days was chosen over termination; the referral deliberation withheld as privileged; “no such named document” defining Hall’s scope.
-
Hall Report denied on primary day
Corporation Counsel denies H.O.T.’s August 6 request for the Hall Report in full, citing attorney-client privilege, while conceding that a written balancing analysis exists. Madrigal wins the Republican primary the same day.
-
Sheriff served in person
H.O.T. serves Sheriff Schmaling personally, as legal custodian, with the three unanswered records requests. No response follows.
-
$31,828.38
County Clerk production shows Racine County paid Crivello Nichols & Hall $31,828.38 for the Hall review (Feb. 2024–Mar. 2025), and $19,586.05 to Attolles Law to oppose Madrigal’s petition to seal her file—a case the County won.
-
A second warning: the Union Grove letter
An anonymous letter alleging inappropriate messages and photos involving students on the Union Grove superintendent’s phone reaches the school board, the principal, and the Union Grove police chief—and, the same day, Sheriff’s Office “Administration.” Investigations is told to start the next morning. By the superintendent’s own account, someone from the Sheriff’s Office visits him at the school that day.
-
“Suspiciously clean”
Racine investigators examine the superintendent’s phones: Snapchat and browsing history deleted. The work phone is later factory-reset. Case transferred to Kenosha County Oct. 27–28.
-
Election
Cary Madrigal loses the race for Racine County Sheriff to Don Vandervest, who campaigned on an independent outside review and full records cooperation.
-
Kenosha makes the arrest. Again.
Kenosha County executes warrants, identifies child sexual abuse material, and arrests the superintendent. Charged Nov. 5 with two felony counts; presumed innocent. The Kenosha detective writes that he had been told of the investigation before it was assigned to Kenosha.
-
Madrigal placed on leave
The Sheriff’s Office confirms Captain Madrigal is on administrative leave pending “a pending internal administrative review of Captain Madrigal’s actions,” and says she is “not the focus or subject of the criminal investigation.” H.O.T. writes to Sheriff-elect Vandervest asking for release of the Hall Report and an outside review.
-
Case file updated
Case details revised. Evidence library lists 31 case files and 5 related public records (36 total).
Evidence library (36)
Case files
Sources & references
- FOX6 Milwaukee — Ex-Racine County deputy sentenced for child sex crimes
- Racine Journal Times — Former RCSO deputy sentenced to 65 years
- Racine Journal Times — Former RCSO deputy pleads guilty to child sex crimes
- Milwaukee Journal Sentinel — Ex-Racine County deputy sentenced to 65 years
- Madison.com / Cap Times — Former sheriff’s deputy sentenced to 65 years
- Wisconsin Circuit Court Access (WCCA) — case lookup
- H.O.T. Government press release (WisPolitics PDF)
- Kenosha Report 26-0106445
- Kenosha Report 26-0106444
- Kenosha Report 26-0106443
- Kenosha Report 26-0106442
Right of Reply / Response Request
- Contacted
- Racine County District Attorney Patricia Hanson; Racine County Corporation Counsel; Racine County Sheriff’s Office; Racine County Human Resources
- Date contacted
- 2026-06-08
- Deadline
- 2026-08-12
- Response received
- Yes
DA Hanson (June 18, 2026): office did not handle Kite’s criminal case; no FBI or DOJ referrals concerning deputies, a supervisor, or a neighboring-county prosecutor referenced in sentencing.
Corporation Counsel (July 22, 2026): hoped to fulfill public-records requests within approximately three weeks; no firm date; no statutory exemption cited.
Sheriff’s Office / HR: records outstanding as of publication.
Corporation Counsel (Aug. 11, 2026): Hall Report request denied in full as privileged; written balancing analysis conceded to exist.
Sheriff’s Office (Nov. 7, 2026, Lt. Luell): Captain Madrigal placed on administrative leave pending “a pending internal administrative review of Captain Madrigal’s actions”; “not the focus or subject of the criminal investigation”; no further comment.
Share this
Support the Work
Your support helps fund public records, legal research, reporting, events and citizen education.
